This post mirrors an update Dr. Ningjing (Natalie) Zhang shared on LinkedIn, lightly edited for the website.
A client came to me recently, referred by an immigration consultant I do not know. We met by video. Then she spent a full week going through the retainer agreement with my assistant. Line by line. Question by question.
“I have been scammed too many times,” she said.
Five years ago, she paid an unlicensed agency in China ¥780,000 RMB, about $156,000 CAD, to enrol her in a provincial nominee stream in a smaller Canadian province. Today the stream does not exist. The nomination did not come. The years did not come back either. We are still working through webforms and access-to-information requests with IRCC to locate her file.
She is not the first such client we have seen at my firm. She is not even the fifth. But the amount is the highest in our firm’s history.
What we have seen from the black-market “consulting” industry
Over several years of practice, this is what I have seen:
- Fabricated employment records
- Fabricated business licences
- An invented dependent child on a visitor visa application
- Job positions that were paid for in order to support a work permit
- Edited bank statements
These agencies can operate out of impressive office towers in Beijing, Shanghai, Guangzhou and other major cities. Some carry local business accreditation. What none of the ones I have encountered carry is a licensed Canadian immigration lawyer or a Regulated Canadian Immigration Consultant (RCIC) on staff. Under section 91 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act, those are the people authorized to be paid for Canadian immigration advice. Misrepresentation on an application can also lead to a five-year inadmissibility for the applicant, not the agent.
Problems on this side of the ocean too
Enforcement in Canada does not match the scale. I have seen a licensed consultant’s number on a shingle while the actual work is done by someone else. I have seen consultants’ Chinese-language web pages advertise Federal Court advocacy, which consultants cannot provide, while the English pages say nothing. And travel agencies in Toronto advertise refugee representation in Chinese on their windows. That is unauthorized practice.
How to protect yourself
- Check that your representative is a lawyer licensed by a Canadian law society or an RCIC listed on the College of Immigration and Citizenship Consultants register. Our guide explains the IRPA s. 91 check.
- Never sign or submit anything you have not read, and never accept “special channels” or guaranteed outcomes.
- Use our red flags self-check list and read about IRCC penalties for representatives.
I am one of a small number of Chinese-native-speaking immigration lawyers in Canada, and I feel a responsibility to keep pushing public legal education for our community. Some days it feels like a mantis raising its arm against a chariot. I would genuinely like to hear from colleagues who have been thinking about the mechanisms that could stop fraud at this scale.
Reposting and quoting. You are welcome to repost, share or quote this post, and you do not need to ask us first. Please credit the source: Dr. Ningjing (Natalie) Zhang, BridgePoint Law, with a link to this page.
About the Author
Dr. Ningjing (Natalie) Zhang is the founder and principal lawyer of BridgePoint Law Professional Corporation, a cross-border immigration law firm with offices in Kingston, Toronto, and Shanghai. She is Vice Chair of the Ontario Bar Association’s Sole, Small and General Practice Section and a returning executive member of the OBA Immigration Section. In 2026, she was named the Inspirational Entrepreneur and one of Kingston’s 40 Under 40 by the Kingston Economic Development Corporation, and she is an author of Thomson Reuters’ Fiduciary Duties in Canada. She practises in English, Mandarin, and Cantonese.
Disclaimer: Everything on the BridgePoint Law website, including this article, is general information for reference only and is not legal advice. Reading it or contacting us does not create a lawyer-client (solicitor-client) relationship. Laws and government policies change often, and every case turns on its own facts. If you need advice on your own situation, you are welcome to book a consultation or contact us.
Talk to a Canadian immigration lawyer. BridgePoint Law advises individuals and businesses across Canada, and on Canada, US and China cross-border matters, on immigration, work permits and Federal Court litigation. Book a consultation with our team in Toronto and Kingston. We work in English, Mandarin, and Cantonese.
